By Sachiko Hayashi / Goodwind Seiling

Sachiko Hayashi is a visual artist who primarily works in video and screen-based interactive media. Her works have been shown widely internationally at various new media festivals. Her video ("boop-oop-a-doop") has been included in DVD compilation "Personas and Personalities" published by Aspect Magazine, Boston. Her net art "Last Meal Requested" was included in CD-ROM GROK, the first educational project by Rhizome, New York.

Fashion and Helmut Newton in SL - What happened to Cindy?

My first impression of SL was that it was very male-dominated. Now, I don’t know any statistics so I am not sure if my impression is correct.

After a-month-or-so in SL and after thousands of comments from my non-artist-SL-friends (”You have to get new skin” “You have to get new hair” “You have to get new clothes” “You have to get new shoes” “You have to get new shape” “You have to get new eys” etc etc), I decided to explore a little more about shops and clothes, mostly to shut off those comments and make my SL life easier. Soon I found that many clothes sold in SL butiques for female avatars are often too revealing and/or too sexy; it has been difficult, if not near impossible, to find good clothes for my female avatar that do not accentuate “female-ness”. I’ve seen seen many female avatars on the streets wearing those sexy clothes (which come nearer to no clothes than clothes) but often I suspect those are probably controlled by RL men. (I hope you all are aware of the fact that many men often like to play females in Virtual world - this has been a well-known fact ever since Habitat.) In SL there seems to exist a special type of beauty-concept for female avatars, whose clothes, hair, shoes, etc. are mostly designed by (and often owned and controlled by) men in RL.

Now the other day, a friend of mine gave me Landmark to an exhibition called “‘Sex and the Virtual Landscape’ - Paolo Bade’s tribute to Helmut Newton” at Avatrait Gallery (slurl.com/secondlife/Simuality/37/209/36/ ). (Our friend Sophie Zhu is one of the set designers, I found out later. Good work, Sophie!) This exhibition could be interesting for either of the following two reasons : if you are into avatar photography, you will find the exhibition interesting and well-informing on “how-to” techniques; if you are not, you will find out what that specific genre is so you can make up your own mind about their approach. What struck me most about this show, however, was neither of those tow points : what struck me was the realisation about the continuation of RL objectification of women in SL. Unfortunately Helmut Newton’s works have never interested me and I’ve never studied them. I don’t know if I have misinterpreted his works but they always symbolised to me the worst type of women objectification. Helmut Newton’s women models are very much like many of those SL women avatars controlled by RL men - a specific sets of beauty components that all together make up stereo-typical beauty of women - superficial interpretation of both “beauty” and “women.”

I don’t know if Paolo Bade is aware of this. I don’t know if his exhibition was meant to be ironical. From the show note I read and what I could see at the exhibit (”This is not sexual exploitation. Instead it is a tribute to strong, forceful women. The women confront the viewer with their nudity, using their bodies and facial expressions. They don’t just look real. They are real” text from Pablo Bade’s exhibition.), I definitely didn’t think so. My first thought at the show was “As if Cindy Sherman never happened…”

Leonard Nimoy

above photo: a parody of one of the most famous photo of H. Newton by Leonard Nimoy

Tags: ,

2 Comments

  1. mr.bichel added these pithy words on 19. November 2007 | Permalink

    Second Life is not male dominated. But the demographic is quite even on the gender subject. If you want to look into the numbers more closely here are some sources regarding your post:

    http://sl.markettruths.com/reports/report.asp?1
    http://blog.secondlife.com/2007/02/09/state-of-the-virtual-world-%E2%80%93-key-metrics-january-2007/

  2. sachiko added these pithy words on 10. December 2007 | Permalink

    ok, here are unofficial “facts”

    i was at a presentation/conference in stockholm (i think it was 1990 or 1991) - one of the talks was held by a woman who was involved with the project which later came to be known as the game “Habitat” when it was sold to Fujitsu (sorry, can’t remember her name). according to her, they found out that 12% (i think it was) of female avatars were actually men in RL.

    an unofficial figure i got from my SL friend regarding female avatars in SL controlled by men are about 20%. i’ll ask him where he got that figure from.

    i have encountered at least 5 female avatars in my short SL life whom i KNOW to be men in RL. (somehow, the opposite (encountering male avatars owned by women) has not happened yet. i know at least three more female avatars i suspect very strongly to be men in RL.

    but to avoid misunderstanding, i have to stress i am all for gender-switch in virtual life. i find it very liberating. why shouldn’t one take advantage of the fact that you can “choose” whatever you like to be? the same goes for race-switch. i know two avatars who switched his and her race from RL to SL.

    when it comes to male-dominance in SL, it is really nothing but my impression (meaning i don’t have any facts to back it up) but i think it is shared by many women. just the other day, i was chatting with my SL friend (female both in RL and SL)who manages a sim for virtual architects. she felt the same way (in fact, i didn’t bring this up - she brought it up). she has now joined a group in SL whose objective is to develop virtual worlds more sympathetic to women. as she put it “i am so tired of being controlled by men.”

One Trackback

  1. […] ). (Our friend Sophie Zhu is one of the set designers, I found out later…. source: Fashion and Helmut Newton in SL - What happened to Cindy?, VIRTUAL […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.